Illinois AG investigating District 211 over ticketing

The Illinois legal professional basic’s office is investigating whether or not one of many state’s largest college districts, positioned in Chicago’s northwest suburbs, violated civil rights legal guidelines when police issued tickets to college students accused of minor misbehavior.

Attorney General Kwame Raoul informed the Township High School District 211 superintendent final week to supply information on college students cited for municipal ordinance violations associated to school-based conduct or truancy, in line with a letter obtained by ProPublica and the Tribune. The office additionally requested information and information associated to suspensions, expulsions, pupil transfers to various faculties and calls to police concerning college students for the reason that begin of the 2018-19 college year.

The practically 12,000-student district operates 5 excessive faculties and two various faculties in Palatine, Hoffman Estates and Schaumburg.

The legal professional basic’s office determined to research District 211 after studying about racial disparities in ticketing throughout the state, which was documented by the Chicago Tribune and ProPublica for the investigation “The Price Kids Pay.” As a part of the investigation, reporters created and revealed a first-of-its-kind database of tickets issued at Illinois public faculties over the final three college years, the explanations police ticketed college students and, when out there, the racial breakdown of scholars who acquired tickets.

Amy Meek, chief of the Civil Rights Bureau within the Illinois legal professional basic’s office, stated District 211 stood out in each the variety of tickets issued and racial disparities within the ticketing. She stated it’s attainable the office will look at different districts as properly.

“This is an issue that we are quite concerned about,” Meek stated.

The legal professional basic’s investigation additionally targets the village of Palatine and its police division, which has jurisdiction at three of the district’s faculties and has officers, generally known as college police consultants, stationed in its buildings. The legal professional basic is in search of paperwork that embrace information on tickets, money owed despatched to collections and truancy fines issued to District 211 college students, according to a letter sent to the village.

The civil rights investigation is the most recent transfer by the state to handle issues uncovered in “The Price Kids Pay,” a collection of tales that, along with the database, have documented practically 12,000 tickets issued in dozens of Illinois districts. Reporters discovered that faculty officers and police have been working collectively to ticket college students for misbehavior at college, leading to fines that might value lots of of {dollars} per ticket.

Within hours of the publication of the primary story final month, state faculties Superintendent Carmen Ayala urged faculties to cease asking police to ticket college students, saying that they had “abdicated their responsibility for student discipline to local law enforcement.” Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker stated he was exploring ways in which he and lawmakers may “make sure that this doesn’t happen anywhere in the state of Illinois.”

Based on out there information from two of the three police companies that work within the district’s faculties, reporters documented 541 tickets issued to college students at District 211 faculties in the course of the previous three college years, most of them for truancy, use or possession of tobacco or vaping units, possession or use of small quantities of hashish, or disorderly conduct.

Most of the ticket information involving District 211 college students have been obtained from the Palatine and Hoffman Estates police departments and didn’t embrace data on the race of the recipients. District 211 doesn’t monitor the tickets that police problem to college students, in line with the district’s chief working officer. But in response to a public information request for ticket information, the district did present data on the race of scholars concerned in 120 truancy incidents. These have been labeled “truancy ticket issued.”

More than half of these 120 incidents concerned Latino college students, regardless that 26% of the district’s college students are Latino. Black college students symbolize lower than 6% of enrollment however acquired 10% of the tickets.

Under a regulation that went into impact in 2019, the Illinois legislature banned faculties from referring truant college students to police in order that they may very well be ticketed.

In a written assertion, District 211 Superintendent Lisa Small stated the district views pupil self-discipline as a manner “to teach students citizenship in the school community, with an emphasis on equity and student success.”

Small stated college officers contain the police when pupil conduct violates a neighborhood ordinance or state or federal regulation, when it poses a security menace within the college, or when different interventions, akin to mother or father conferences, aren’t efficient.

“These responses are implemented regardless of the student’s race, ethnicity, socioeconomic background or other factors,” she wrote. “We continually review our practices to ensure we are acting fairly and equitably, responding appropriately and ensuring the results are in the best interest of all students.”

The Palatine village supervisor, village legal professional and police chief didn’t reply to requests for remark.

Palatine is only one of three cities whose police departments have jurisdiction in District 211. Because the district doesn’t preserve information of when college students get cited by police, acquiring a whole image of ticketing practices within the district would require getting information from all three municipalities. Meek stated the legal professional basic’s office should additionally request data from the opposite two, Schaumburg and Hoffman Estates.

State civil rights inquiries look at whether or not there’s a “pattern and practice” of unequal remedy primarily based on race or different traits, akin to gender. Meek stated college districts or municipalities may be in violation of civil rights legal guidelines when their insurance policies and practices have a disparate affect on sure teams of individuals, even when it isn’t intentional.

In requesting information associated to ticketing and different types of self-discipline, the legal professional basic’s office requested for data on the scholars’ race and gender and on whether or not they have a incapacity. The office additionally sought data that might point out the explanations for the tickets and the price of the fines.

In Palatine, information present, police issued 240 tickets from July 2018 to August 2020 to folks underneath 18 at Palatine High School and William Fremd High School. About 170 of these tickets have been for truancy. Most of the truancy tickets have been written after the regulation banning faculties from referring truant college students to police for tickets went into impact.

Ticketing by police was way more frequent at Palatine High School, the place practically 48% of scholars are Latino, than at Fremd, the place about 10% of scholars are Latino.

Excluding parking tickets, Palatine police issued extra ordinance violation tickets at Palatine High School than anyplace else within the village in the course of the time interval examined, in line with reporters’ evaluation of police information. Nearly 3 times as many tickets have been issued at the highschool as on the subsequent commonest website for ticketing: Nellie’s Gastropub and Concert Hub, also referred to as Durty Nellie’s.

At Hoffman Estates’ two excessive faculties, the Tribune-ProPublica investigation recognized greater than 300 tickets issued to juveniles in the course of the previous three college years for disorderly conduct, possession or use of tobacco, e-cigarettes or hashish, or truancy. The fines totaled practically $37,000, and about $13,000 was unpaid, information present. Some Illinois municipalities, together with Hoffman Estates, ship debt from unpaid pupil tickets to collections.

Schaumburg police wouldn’t point out which of the tickets issued to younger folks went to college students at Schaumburg High School.

One former pupil at Hoffman Estates High School recounted this week how she was ticketed for disorderly conduct on the college when she was 17 years outdated. She stated she had put her palms out throughout a verbal confrontation after college. Police information present she was ticketed in March 2019 and fined $200.

The former pupil, who’s multiracial, stated she informed college officers that the ticket was unfair and didn’t pay it, she stated in an interview. Now a 20-year-old faculty pupil, she acquired a discover in January from a collections company that she owes $270.

The girl stated she was glad that the legal professional basic is investigating District 211. “Hoffman has become more diverse in the past couple of years, and there is a difference in how they treat African American students, any kind of minority students. It is different treatment,” she stated. “Something should have been done a long time ago because it has been going on for a while.”

Meek stated publicly out there information on suspensions and expulsions, in addition to earlier lawsuits in opposition to the district, performed a task within the determination to launch a civil rights investigation. Meek additionally stated the office is conscious that the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights opened an investigation in December into whether or not a person pupil had been disciplined unfairly due to their race and incapacity standing. That investigation is pending.

In addition, District 211 settled a federal civil rights lawsuit in 2019 that concerned a Black pupil who had been ticketed at Palatine High School.

In that case, filed in 2016, a Palatine senior alleged {that a} police officer on the college used extreme pressure when he chased her down a hallway and pinned her to the bottom. According to the lawsuit and a police report that turned a part of the case report, the lady had been working after her sister as a result of the sister, additionally a pupil, spilled milk on her. The officer arrested each sisters and put them in cells on the police division. Police wrote every lady a ticket for violating a village ordinance prohibiting disorderly conduct.

The district, the police officer and college officers named within the lawsuit denied wrongdoing, however the district agreed to settle the case. District officers stated they might not find a report of how a lot the settlement was for.

The district and Palatine police have till June 30 to supply information sought by the legal professional basic. If the investigation reveals violations of civil rights regulation, the legal professional basic may negotiate with the district to vary its practices, search a court-monitored consent decree or file a lawsuit in opposition to the district.

Meek stated the investigation may take a year to finish.

“We also encourage people to reach out to the Civil Rights Bureau if they have complaints or concerns about other districts they want to bring to our attention,” she added.

Smith Richards is a Tribune reporter. Cohen is a Chicago-based reporter for ProPublica.

[email protected]

Back to top button