Top New York Judge Not Complying With Vaccine Mandate

NEW YORK (AP) — A decide on New York’s highest court docket has been referred to a disciplinary fee and could possibly be kicked off the bench for failing to adjust to a rule requiring proof of vaccination towards COVID-19.

Judge Jenny Rivera, certainly one of seven jurists on the state’s Court of Appeals, is barred from court docket services and has been working remotely since October, court docket officers stated. She is certainly one of 4 judges statewide who’ve been referred to the state’s Commission on Judicial Conduct for being out of compliance with the mandate that applies to all court docket personnel.

The Court of Appeals is New York’s equal of the U.S. Supreme Court.

“We had made it clear from the outset that any Judge not in compliance subjects themselves to a referral to the Commission on Judicial Conduct for their determination,” courts spokesperson Lucian Chalfen stated.

Asked about Rivera’s standing, Chalfen stated: “She is not in compliance with the court’s vaccination policy.”

Responding to a message left with Rivera’s chambers, Court of Appeals spokesperson Gary Spencer stated: “If true, any referral would be confidential under the Judiciary Law.”

Rivera, who was appointed to the Court of Appeals by former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in 2013, has been taking part in hearings by video, questioning attorneys by way of a big tv monitor positioned subsequent to her colleagues on the bench within the Albany courtroom.

She was absent from Tuesday’s ceremony, attended by Gov. Kathy Hochul, celebrating new appeals court docket judges.

New York’s state court docket system requires all staff to be vaccinated towards COVID-19, a coverage it put in place final year. On March 21, the state court docket system notified 156 court docket staff that they failed to satisfy qualification for employment and can be fired if they didn’t present proof of vaccination by April 4.

Chalfen stated of these staff, 103 are being despatched termination letters, one has resigned, 11 have stated they’re retiring, and 41 have chosen to adjust to the mandate and can return to responsibility.

That deadline didn’t apply to judges, who can solely be eliminated by the Commission on Judicial Conduct. The fee has by no means sanctioned or eliminated a Court of Appeals decide, based on a database of its selections.

Rivera can proceed working as a decide whereas the fee course of performs out. The timeline for that course of hasn’t been launched.

On its web site, the Commission on Judicial Conduct says all complaints stay confidential till it renders a public dedication {that a} decide ought to be admonished, censured, eliminated or retired, or if the decide topic to a criticism has waived confidentiality.

A spokesperson for the fee, Marisa Harrison, declined to remark.

Since its inception in 1978, the fee has made determinations in 912 circumstances, about two-thirds of them involving low-level city or village court docket justices. The fee has eliminated 176 judges from office and publicly censured 342 judges. Another 114 judges have retired or resigned on account of the fee’s proceedings.

Follow Michael Sisak on Twitter at

Back to top button